Isle of Reveries: A true spiritual successor to the Game Boy Zelda games
Review of Isle of Reveries
It's impossible to talk about Isle of Reveries without comparing to Mina the Hollower. They have both been in development for years, both came out at close to the same time, and both are purported to be love letters to the Game Boy Zelda games (particularly the Oracle series).
I wrote previously about Mina the Hollower, and primarily my disappointment in the disconnect between the aesthetics and the actual game design. While waiting for Mina, another game was hovering on my radar: Isle of Reveries. Aesthetically, it looks about as good as Mina the Hollower, but is a bit more strict with its limitations. Isle of Reveries keeps to the Game Boy aspect ratio and stays more true to the constraints of the inspiration (I think it may stretch the sprite limit a little bit, but the resolution and color limitations match the Game Boy Color very faithfully). It's the game design that pushes this over its sibling.
Story ¶
The titular Isle of Reveries (which appears to float above the world, which people on the island call "The Surface"), where people believe that wishes are granted. It appears that this is a false promise, however, as wishing seems to steal the essence of the pilgrims, turning them into piles of gold and leaving their souls to wander as wraiths.
You play as Lief, an owl whose brother has passed away, making his own pilgrimage to the island to possibly wish his brother back to life.
This has notable similarities to Link's Awakening. Much in Isle of Reveries has a dreamlike quality. The Reveries themselves are spoken of after each dungeon, and there's a dreamlike layer of unreality to the whole scenario. Similar to Link's Awakening, there is the theme of wishing and making wishes. The Goddess is similar to the Wind Fish, regularly spoken of but never seen.
Spoilers
As I proceeded in the game, I noticed many things that were never touched upon or talked about. Many areas, especially deep in some caves, looked organic, like you were walking through the inside of a vast beast.
Through decoding the tablets strewn about the island, it eventually becomes apparent that there is a more nefarious undercurrent to the events and the goddess. The island itself seems to be some sort of organic being, and the entity known as the "goddess" is either that being or a malicious entity that has taken over the island.
Gameplay ¶
This game is through-and-through a Zelda-like adventure game at its finest. Combat is there at a decent difficulty (some bosses killed me at least a dozen times), but it's far from the focus. This is a puzzle adventure game at its core. Past the second dungeon, the game opens up and makes you explore a bit and have to find your own way, and it's sublime. It's a unique pace to this kind of game to make you go out of your way to explore about half of the world between two dungeons. I thought I was getting lost, but it was apparently what was expected of me.
The copy-and-spawn mechanic is a gimmick that surprised me; I was certain that something like that would break the game, make you short-circuit puzzles, and lead to soft-locks, but it's extremely well thought through and planned out. I had the same concern about an item I obtained in Level 4, but that one also wasn't too bad.
Compared to Mina the Hollower, where the gimmick was mostly a combat tool, often a movement technique, and very rarely a component in solving a puzzle, the mechanics in this game are in another league. They're used everywhere, and they're used very intelligently.
Complaints ¶
I only have a few minor complaints. Some parts of the game suffer from a degree of tedium. Level 4 has a lot of very tedious and repetitive backtracking that didn't feel wholly necessary. I didn't deduce the exact right way to do everything, and exploring the possibilities had me running to the top floor and back over and over again, burning dozens of minutes just on that back-and-forth.
There are a few soft-locks I was able to hit in the game, but only one wasn't due to a glitch. I was able to use the Level 4 item to end up in a part of the level that I couldn't then get my way back out of. This was on the Nintendo Switch, so there's a possibility it's patched on other releases, given how slow Nintendo is with pushing updates.
Conclusion ¶
Isle of Reveries is the game that I had wished Mina the Hollower was. It is a best-in-class example of a game taking an existing formula to its limit and adding a gimmick that is fully planned-out. If you like the Zelda games for the exploration and puzzle solving, this game is a must. If you felt let down by Mina the Hollower when you realized it's just a 2D Souls game, this is the palate cleanser you desire.
Score: / 5